PUBLIC FORUMS/GENERAL FORUM

Topic Title: Game Design Flaw (Simple Topic)

Topic starter: Professor

Topic started: 19:50:10 4th Feb 2006

Posts: 37 Last post: 16:33:45 5th Feb 2006 by GholaBashar

Previous 1 2 3 4  Next

Professor Posted: 19:50:10 4th Feb 2006

Posts: 5830

Topics: 405

Location: China

Gender: Male

ISP: MSN



19:31:16 | Professor ship Sphinx33b has been destroyed by Baras.
19:31:11 | Professor ship CVS 7 has been destroyed by SmartFox.
19:31:10 | Professor ship RBA 3 has been destroyed by SmartFox.
19:31:10 | Professor ship RBA 8 has been destroyed by SmartFox.
19:31:10 | Professor ship RBA 6 has been destroyed by Baras.
19:31:09 | Professor ship Sphinx33b has been destroyed by SmartFox.
19:31:05 | Professor ship A24 Oblivion has been destroyed by SmartFox.
19:31:04 | Professor ship Kotica 8 has been destroyed by SmartFox.
19:31:03 | Professor ship CVS 5 has been destroyed by SmartFox.
19:31:03 | Professor ship CVS 6 has been destroyed by SmartFox.
19:31:02 | Professor ship CVS 4 has been destroyed by SmartFox.
19:31:02 | Professor ship CVS 3 has been destroyed by SmartFox.
19:31:01 | Professor ship A37 Gauntlet has been destroyed by Baras.

There was a fleet cloud cover of more than 60 ships, which was significantly longer than would have been possible to attack these ships with normal game attack commands. I am not sure HOW SmartFox and Baras were able to see past the lower named ships, but they did, in a way that is not possible using the standard game interface.

The use of non-standard game tools, such as autotrain, autoprobe, and autoattack scripts or other tools for getting arround game commands is not part of the game interface, and harm caused to players as a result of proven abuses of such tools is considered a bug and will be fixed whenever possible, including the harm cause and benefits from such tools or non-standard interfaces to the game.

In general, as long as such tools appear to be hard to detect and also cause minimal harm to other players in the game, I have relatively high tolerance for their use. But, using them in a way that gives an advantage not possible to be acheived by other players is not acceptable.

Whether or not a ship cloud is a good or bad feature in the game, it has been a feature of the game and getting arround it without using normal game commands is not acceptable as a means of creating an unfair advantage.




__________________________
"Of all the things I have lost, I miss my mind the most."

SmartFox Posted: 19:57:13 4th Feb 2006

Posts: 1557

Topics: 112

Location: Lithuania

Gender: Male



You stupid man.. and very stupid man.... Allways was different between trade with ships and attack ships.. allways it was , and we play without any advage.. just you don't have exp like warrior... thats all... ;)




__________________________




Baras Posted: 19:59:20 4th Feb 2006

Posts: 711

Topics: 62

Location: Lithuania

Gender: Male

ISP: Skynet



It is true man ;) and always welcome.




__________________________
To fight for us, for our country!
+370 61005775

kotica Posted: 20:01:10 4th Feb 2006

Posts: 935

Topics: 84

Location: United States

Gender: Male



smartfox - your kung foo is the best




__________________________
Men never do evil so completely and cheerfully as when they do it from religious conviction. - Blaise Pascal

I only know what I read on the internet.

SmartFox Posted: 20:03:50 4th Feb 2006

Posts: 1557

Topics: 112

Location: Lithuania

Gender: Male



Here was made 2 serious mistakes.. and we profit only it. So... Good luck next time :D




__________________________




Baras Posted: 20:05:55 4th Feb 2006

Posts: 711

Topics: 62

Location: Lithuania

Gender: Male

ISP: Skynet



Thanks SF for good job ;)




__________________________
To fight for us, for our country!
+370 61005775

kotica Posted: 20:06:52 4th Feb 2006

Posts: 935

Topics: 84

Location: United States

Gender: Male



2 mistakes? care to enlighten us?




__________________________
Men never do evil so completely and cheerfully as when they do it from religious conviction. - Blaise Pascal

I only know what I read on the internet.

SmartFox Posted: 20:09:35 4th Feb 2006

Posts: 1557

Topics: 112

Location: Lithuania

Gender: Male



It was 2 strategy mistakes... Like I said no exp in war.

:LTC:




__________________________




kotica Posted: 20:15:34 4th Feb 2006

Posts: 935

Topics: 84

Location: United States

Gender: Male



fair enuf. but u should add 'in skylords' to the end of your sentence :D




__________________________
Men never do evil so completely and cheerfully as when they do it from religious conviction. - Blaise Pascal

I only know what I read on the internet.

Professor Posted: 20:16:59 4th Feb 2006

Posts: 5830

Topics: 405

Location: China

Gender: Male

ISP: MSN



Iiridayn has confirmed that there was an error in the specification or original design of the attack function, such that it behaved differently from other commands in the game. This, in my opinion, was a design mistake.

It appears that SmartFox and Baras did not cheat. They did, however, exploit a feature of the game which was unknown to most players, including me and Iiridayn, and it is a feature that I consider to be a [] in game design due to inconsistency of user interface when such inconsistency is unknown to most users (including to the system administrator and game owner).

As such, no points earned by LTC will be reversed. They did not cheat. They exploited a flaw in design which was inherent to the game, and which was generally unknown, but it was not an example of cheating. It was an example of a better understanding of game quirks and oddities than I myself have or than Iiridayn had of how the game code was written.

The inconsistency in the way transports pirate and fighters attack will be fixed, as it is a game bug to have these two similar functions behave differently. For now, we will change the game so that both fighters and transports view action page screens in the same order or priority.

However, I will also raise this as a topic for discussion with SL counsel to decide HOW these functions should work in the future (should a ship cloud be possible for either fighters or transports, or should both fighters and transports see ships in random order if more than one page).




__________________________
"Of all the things I have lost, I miss my mind the most."

Iiridayn Posted: 20:23:46 4th Feb 2006

Posts: 1643

Topics: 98

Location: United States

Gender: Male



Code has been changed.




__________________________
SkyLords Head Programmer

Spelled: I I R I (not irii, irri, or iri).

Force of nature.

Previous 1 2 3 4  Next

PUBLIC FORUMS
TICKETS
LANGUAGE FORUMS
SKYLORDS CHAT