| Vigilante | Posted: 12:02:10 30th May 2005 |
Posts: 1347 Topics: 58 Location: United States Gender: Male |
Look see people agree with me prof that there is no need for a council.there is nothing wrong with the system we have now in deciding changes!
|
| bpmsac | Posted: 12:02:42 30th May 2005 |
Posts: 1551 Topics: 53 Location: United States Gender: Male |
but why should have a clan of 3 be equal to a clan of 12....after all... the larger clan should have more say because it represents more people.... nad i see your concern of inactives....but there should be some rule about log in...and i guess the punishment for having inactives is that there will be a lower point/member ranking
|
| Vigilante | Posted: 12:09:37 30th May 2005 |
Posts: 1347 Topics: 58 Location: United States Gender: Male |
Wait a second how many people actully live in the US who play this game? In england, diplomacy consits of two councils, in SL way this would be a council of 'New players' and a council of 'Vets', the Vets + Newb councils would both have to agree on it first efore the change is accepted. Also you would have to hold elections for goverment every round incase the members of SL arnt happy with the way things are being run with the council.
|
| MinderBinder | Posted: 12:14:35 30th May 2005 |
Posts: 1599 Topics: 54 Location: United States Gender: Male |
You cant have a noob council, noob is subjective is a restarted vet a noob, is less than 3 stars a noob, when do they get booted, what about a 5 star player who comes back but never had an hw are they still a noob?
|
| swimerdude62 | Posted: 12:18:11 30th May 2005 |
Posts: 1874 Topics: 127 Gender: Male |
How about we jsut looka t teh concuil as a way of professer hearing what the players wnat intstead of listing to eveyr single request to changes made. thats all it is. adn i cna't belive that a 17 year old kid saw that ebfore most of you did.
|
| MinderBinder | Posted: 12:18:56 30th May 2005 |
Posts: 1599 Topics: 54 Location: United States Gender: Male |
Its a council, a body of advisors to give advise based on their respective clans interests, it doesnt matter if one clan can give more advise or not, the prof knows which clan is bigger, he makes the decisions the council does nothing, in the end, its a cabinet nothing more, jus slightly more democratic, it does not undermine the sl community as they would have representaion both in the council and in the profs periodic polls, it does not undermine noobs as even lacking a definite definition of noob they have clans that are made for their interests and they can vote in polls, this council does not replace open debate, but sometimes the prof makes changes based entirely on whate he thinks should happen, this is solely for those cases to give the people of sl slightly more say...
|
| MinderBinder | Posted: 12:19:45 30th May 2005 |
Posts: 1599 Topics: 54 Location: United States Gender: Male |
and swimmerdude beat me to it with a slightly more concise way of putting it, but I guess us 17 years olds are on the ball
|
| Vigilante | Posted: 12:20:41 30th May 2005 |
Posts: 1347 Topics: 58 Location: United States Gender: Male |
I just said its the way English diplomacy goes. Yes I do hate you Neggy thats why im not going to let you worm yourself into every decision made and kick the rest of us out but a few. If theres to be a council forum then it should be public, just not let everyone post there, at least then the SL community can decide wether its corrupt or not.
|
| MinderBinder | Posted: 12:22:36 30th May 2005 |
Posts: 1599 Topics: 54 Location: United States Gender: Male |
it doesnt make decisions, it gives advice for the prof to make decisions
|
| swimerdude62 | Posted: 12:24:01 30th May 2005 |
Posts: 1874 Topics: 127 Gender: Male |
Vig dude you ahve it all wron the conciul isn't voting on anything.. its jsut to team down all the stuff the proffesser has to deal with. and it is sad that your that blind ebcouse you don't like neggy. all he would be doing is orgnaizing it. thats it and yet you keep on gogin liek they are goign to be important./ they aren't the game is goign to be inmportant.
|